2020-03-12
Legal Articles

The right to a view from your property

Home / Knowledge base / The right to a view

Posted by Mary Rouse on 10 April 2010

Mary Rouse - Property Litigation Lawyer
Mary Rouse Partner

It is a long established principle in English Law, first recorded in 1610, that a land owner can not protect the view that he has from that land; the rationale is that it would unduly limit the freedom to build on one's own land and thereby hinder beneficial development. However this basic premise, under specific circumstances, has been successfully challenged in the Court of Appeal.

Case of Dennis v Davies

The case of Dennis v Davies (2009) concerned a dispute regarding a modern development, adjacent to the River Thames, which had been specifically designed, and sold, on the basis that each property had a river view.  

The owner of one of the riverside houses decided to build an extension that would obstruct the views of the river from neighbouring properties within the development. Under the traditional law, the neighbouring owners had lost their view, not only potentially damaging property values, but also providing a precedent for other properties being developed and thus blocking other river views. 

However, all the property owners in the development were subject to, and had the benefit of, a specific covenant that they would ‘not cause a nuisance or annoyance’ to their neighbours. The first part of that covenant was of no help because an obstruction of a view is not an actionable claim; however, the part concerning annoyance was and, on that basis, the development was blocked.

This is a fairly exceptional circumstance and the Court took into account the fact that this development had been designed so that each and every property would benefit from river views. Furthermore, the wide covenant that applied to each property ensured that neighbouring owners should not cause an annoyance to each other. This case has highlighted the importance of reviewing title documents when a dispute arises over land.

The general position remains therefore that there is no right to a view; however, as can be seen, a precedent has been set for exceptions to apply.

About the author

Mary Rouse

Partner

Mary is an experienced property litigation lawyer.

Mary Rouse

Mary is an experienced property litigation lawyer.

Recent articles

30 July 2020 Rethinking the landlord / tenant relationship

We have been following the travails of the high street for over 12 months where changing shopping habits, business rates and rent increases have been contributing to a growing strain on many landlord / tenant relationships. The Covid-19 pandemic has not only turned a bad situation critical for many retailers and hospitality venues but has also turned the spotlight on the wider commercial sector too. Almost all businesses operating across the country have suffered financially to a greater or lesser extent as result of the economic downturn precipitated by the imposition of lockdown in March.

Read article
30 July 2020 Bankrupts fail in claim to have interests in land revested in them

The claim by Mr and Mrs Brake (Brake v Swift), heard in the High Court in May, to have a cottage and adjacent land revested in them under Section 283A of the Insolvency Act 1986, was set against a background of convoluted litigation extending over a number of years, described by Matthews HHJ as ‘complex’. The claimants had been made bankrupt in 2015 and the matter before the Court concentrated on whether or not the property concerned was, indeed, the claimants’ principal residence at the time of the bankruptcy.

Read article
29 July 2020 Remote witnessing of wills – a sign of the times

The law governing how a will is witnessed dates back to 1837 and for good reason. The requirement for two people (neither of whom can inherit from the will they are witnessing) to be physically present at the signing of a will is designed to, among other things, prevent fraud and the exercise of undue influence. That is, until the Covid-19 pandemic struck.

Read article
Contact
How can we help?
01926 732512
CALL BACK